Test 2

Please select your preferred language.

請選擇你慣用的語言。

请选择你惯用的语言。

English
中文简体
台灣繁體
香港繁體

登入

記住我

初到 Fridae?

Fridae Mobile

Advertisement
Highlights

More About Us

新聞&特寫

« 較新的 | 較舊的 »
24 Feb 2011

Gay activists slam TV exposé of gay men, organise protest

The gay community has expressed their outrage after a TV channel in Hyderabad, India carried a nearly 7-minute long news story that outed close to a dozen men who had their photographs and personal details on a gay personals website.

Gay rights groups in India are demanding a public apology and are also considering legal action after a TV channel in the southern Indian city of Hyderabad broadcast a nearly 7-minute long news story that outed close to a dozen men who had their photographs on a gay personals website.

Screenshots of the TV9 news report which was uploaded to the TV station’s own Youtube channel on Wednesday. The video has since been removed by Youtube. The photographs have been pixelated by Fridae to protect the privacy of the men featured in the video.

The Telugu-language report, which ran with a headline roughly translated as “Gay culture rampant in Hyderabad,” showed covertly filmed scenes of men in gay dance clubs as well as photos and other personal information displayed on the online profiles of local gay men.

The video by TV9 also featured two recorded telephone conversations between the reporter and two men who had listed their phone numbers on the website. The men, whose profile photographs were shown on screen, were asked to reveal their names, occupations, university, sexual preferences and where they live.

Accompanied by suspenseful music, their reporter observed that "gay culture in Hyderabad is increasing drastically" as "boys pursuing boys has become fashionable," according to an English translation being circulated. Another reporter declared that white-collar workers and highly qualified students were becoming “slaves to a lifestyle which is against the ‘natural way.’”

Although consensual sexual relations between men was decriminalised by the Delhi High Court in 2009, homosexuality is largely regarded to be a taboo.

India’s Ndtv.com reported today that one of the young men who was outed in the video had allegedly tried to commit suicide after his parents saw him in the TV report.

Since the video was uploaded to the TV station’s own Youtube channel on Wednesday, gay rights groups have fiercely condemned the TV station’s “blatant act of privacy and rights violation.” The video has since been removed by Youtube.

“Your news item has hunted down private profiles of individuals from a gay social networking website and then have aired not only their names and their pictures, it has also called them up in a clear attempt at entrapment and prodded them with leading questions about their private sexual lives, for the sole purpose of providing unnecessary titillation to your general viewers.” Aditya Bondyopadhyay, a lawyer and Director of LGBT rights group Adhikaar, wrote in a letter to TV9’s legal department highlighting the National Broadcasters Association Guidelines that they have breached.

Under Code 6 the guidelines, TV channels “must not intrude on private lives, or personal affairs of individuals, unless there is a clearly established larger and identifiable public interest for such a broadcast. The underlying principle that news channels abide by is that the intrusion of the private spaces, records, transcripts, telephone conversations and any other material will not be for salacious interest, but only when warranted in the public interest.”

Code 9 states: “As a guiding principle, sting and under cover operations should be a last resort of news channels in an attempt to give the viewer comprehensive coverage of any news story. News channels will not allow sex and sleaze as a means to carry out sting operations…”

Adhikaar further called for TV9 to be “held solely responsible for any harm or injury that is caused to any member of the LGBT community of Hyderabad or anywhere else in India where there is reception of your Telugu news channel, since your news item is clearly a case of incitement to targeted violence or discrimination against member of the LGBT community.”

To make amends for these violations, the letter demands that the TV 9 “airs an apology each, separately and specifically, to each and every individual who has been maliciously and unethically targeted” by the channel, as well as to publish a “news article apologising to the entire LGBT community of India whose security, constitutionally protected liberties and freedoms, and fundamental rights to a life of dignity, have been severely jeopardised by [the station’s] unscientific, prejudiced, unsubstantiated, malicious, and vicious content and comments.”

It also demands that TV9 “widely advertises its apologies in every news daily (newspaper) published in the city of Hyderabad in Telugu and English Language, on two separate days, so that the repairing of the damage that your news broadcast has caused to the safety and security of individuals and to an entire community is impactful and of a sustained nature.” 

A peaceful protest has been planned for Friday, Feb 25 from 5.30pm at TV9 Maharashtra's office in Mumbai. For updates, visit “United against TV9” Facebook event page.

India

讀者回應

1. 2011-02-24 22:16  
Go get 'em!!! What bastards!!!

Is there a petition that can be circulated worldwide???

Someone in India should start one and circulate it in every GLBT media outlet!!
2. 2011-02-24 22:18  
Disgusting but unfortunately not surprising
3. 2011-02-24 23:08  
I've never read news like poor ppl is on the rise, pls do something.

News always in the name of "public interest", u dont hv to be rocket science to know that it is just their $$$ interest.

Modern Indian seem becoming narrow minded compare to their ancestor. Richard Gere kissed an Indian girl, ya fuckin big deal as compare to kama sutra in temples.
4. 2011-02-25 03:11  
Find the TV channel's website, send them protest emails. Find their YouTube channel, fill the comments with protest.

Will this make a difference? Who knows. Backward thinking and ignorance fuelled by self righteousness is a difficult combo to "cure".
5. 2011-02-25 03:11  
Find the TV channel's website, send them protest emails. Find their YouTube channel, fill the comments with protest.

Will this make a difference? Who knows. Backward thinking and ignorance fuelled by self righteousness is a difficult combo to "cure".
6. 2011-02-25 04:36  
THEY'RE RUINING THE GUYS' LIFE......DISGUSTING!!
7. 2011-02-25 08:22  
Sad sad sad.

What to do , Blame mankind. We buy only sensationlised news . So the media will create more of such news so they make $$$$$$

8. 2011-02-25 10:14  
No matahari... dont blame mankind... Blame religion. Without the taboos that religion peddles nobody would give a damn about who did what to who in private
9. 2011-02-25 11:16  
In this case, I can't see the direct involvement of religion. I see bad or lack of professional ethics and terrible judgement of the decision makers...
10. 2011-02-25 13:12  
In a country where ignorance is rife, this is hardly a surprise. When the majority of straight people still believe that homosexuality is still a life-style, and still have to learn and realise that it's not a choice, tolerance seems to be THEE one aspect in life most people have to learn. Either straight or gay, other people's sexual proclivities do not feature in my life, and really make no difference in anyone's personality or how they do their job. When will people learn that???

But then again, newspapers, magazines and TV stations are just out for sensationalism, trying to improve their ratings, when in actual fact they turn out to be blight on society.
11. 2011-02-25 13:17  
Its bad but dont forget gay websites for personal ads are open to the pulic. You are stupid to put ur phone number on any website, as it then becomes public domain.

There are no restrictions to anyone signing up fpr these websites so anyone who posts a photo can be a target.

Sorry bt if u want to be closeted thats fine but dont put photos on the internet.
12. 2011-02-25 16:17  
how totally ignorant, the indian media are well known for sensationalising events, and demonising sub cultures, they need to move with the times if they want to be the industrial superpower they are striving to be.
13. 2011-02-25 17:34  
I'm a bit surprised by the idea that people "publishing" their profiles or going to a public bar are somehow going to keep what they're doing private.
14. 2011-02-25 19:37  
sigh! more crap happening it's not as if these poor guys are 'down low' cheating on their wives or running for parliament as 'god fearing family men'.. this experience is a lesson to guys in less socially progressive countries to be ever thoughtful and cautious.
15. 2011-02-25 22:09  
At least the person they outed was shown to have an XL size cock. Probably planetromeo business is booming there since the story.
16. 2011-02-25 23:50  
i feel sorry for people isolated in tv stations who have little exposure to the natural world. all they can do is use their typing hands to describe what they believe to be the natural way. it is a less accurate depiction of nature than making shadow puppets with hands.
17. 2011-02-25 23:50  
i feel sorry for people isolated in tv stations who have little exposure to the natural world. all they can do is use their typing hands to describe what they believe to be the natural way. it is a less accurate depiction of nature than making shadow puppets with hands.
18. 2011-02-25 23:50  
i feel sorry for people isolated in tv stations who have little exposure to the natural world. all they can do is use their typing hands to describe what they believe to be the natural way. it is a less accurate depiction of nature than making shadow puppets with hands.
回應#19於於2011-02-26 13:40被作者刪除。
20. 2011-02-26 13:44  
Hope this issue will eventually goes to court. Teach the tv station a big lesson. Let them pay for the price of what it has done to these people. Terrible !
21. 2011-02-26 13:46  
The shame is that these so-called exposes are happening even as rape of females by heterosexual men is steeply on the rise in India. Not a day goes by in India without reports of at least one female person getting raped by one or more heterosexual men; the female in question being a young child, an elderly woman, a handicapped woman, a foreign tourist, or anyone else that happens to be available. Statistics show that a majority of these rapes are by family members and/or friends known to the victims or their families. Today's Times of India in fact reports the gang rape, by four heterosexual men, of two foreign women who had travelled to India to render social service among rural children.

It is this same heterosexual community that condemns the gay community for "lowering India's morals". That is indeed the mindless refrain in all these homophobic attacks: that gay people are importing "filthy Western practices" and "sullying the pristine purity of India". They blithely ignore the fact that it is THEY who are shaming India in the eyes of the whole world with their relentless attacks on the female gender. While there are many sensible heterosexuals in India that have no problems with other people being gay, they are largely silent and neutral in this battle; the homophobes unfortunately form the majority in terms of sheer numbers and, in India, might is right.

India is a male-dominated society that defends the male sex at the expense of the female sex. Rape of females is not seen as a threat by these men (unless the victim happens to be their own daughter). Men rape; women get raped; that is how god has structured the human physiology. So, men sit pretty in the comforting belief that they can only be the predators and never the prey. Men in India can go anywhere safely, at any time, all by themselves; females must herd together for safety, and must never venture anywhere alone or without taking great care, and even then they can be subjected to crude suggestive remarks, invitations and groping by total strangers unless moving around in a very public place in broad daylight. If any single female raises a complaint of molestation, the first question she is asked is, what were you doing there all by yourself? The police are annoyed that she has created this problem for them by venturing out alone instead of "sensibly" going with some male companions.


Female rape is generally rationalised by saying things like: having sex is human nature, prostitution must be legalised so that these poor men need not be forced to turn to other women, etc. But, the attitude towards gay sex is different. These same heterosexual men, formerly secure in their role as predators, now feel threatened themselves because they feel they too can end up as the prey. They too can be studied, stalked or raped. Damn! No longer are they on top of the rape chain. No longer is it their prerogative to sit on the sidewalks mentally stripping passing females and making lewd comments. They are now uncomfortable at the thought that perhaps other men could be mentally stripping them naked in the same way; what a shocking idea. To them, any gay sex is like an attack on “their own kind”; an attack on the male gender itself. Any news of gay sex, even consensual, is received with more outrage than all the thousands of female rapes taking place in India annually put together. How DARE they attack one of our own kind! This is why the most virulent homophobes also happen to be the most “macho”, “he-man” types of men who think nothing of raping women and who like to boast of their female conquests. These two attitudes go hand in hand. In some of these things, India is only one step behind Islamic countries.

Gay people in India need be aware of the reality in India; they need to grow up and show more sense in the way they go about their search for partners. Unless you are completely "out" and don't care who knows that you are gay, do not provide personal information in online ads that can identify you, like clear photos, phone number, and so on. Before inviting some stranger to your home, arrange a meeting in a neutral venue through email and, only after that, decide if you want to go ahead with your relationship. Also, refuse to provide phone number, picture, etc. to some anonymous person online. If you need to know what they look like, the only reliable way is a video chat where you can actually see them talking to you. If someone sends you "their" picture, do not naively believe it is indeed their own picture. Or, the picture could indeed be theirs but 20 years old. When you do meet up with someone, avoid taking photos or videos of the two of you in "compromising positions", meaning naked, kissing, etc. Be aware that you can be blackmailed or otherwise shamed. If you still end up being blackmailed, do NOT give in, as blackmail NEVER stops. Try to get in touch with someone you can trust, like social activists and counsellors, and explore your options.

Also, avoid posting pictures of genitals in your personals ads. Indian gay personal ads are full of revolting self-pictures of genitals. Why? Is that all there is to being gay? Indian gays just make the whole gay community look like depraved and sex-crazed brutes; they are letting down the gay community by their naivete.

22. 2011-02-26 17:24  
i don't mean to sound racist, but even here in Malaysia, the Indian men lacks basic morality ._.
23. 2011-02-26 20:38  
This is freakish!!! They must be sooo freaking desperate... I hope the so-called journalist and everyone who had a part in this get their own lives scrutinized by some freak and aired over some form of media! This is downright crude!
24. 2011-02-26 22:26  
Such a horrible story.. It's really make me sick.. It makes India to be the last countries i want to visit..
25. 2011-02-27 15:24  
how dare they go and out people in this way! Its disgusting!
26. 2011-02-27 22:57  
their ethics, professionalism in journalism and humanity were blinded by their insatiable desire to get higher ratings...higher no. of viewers and money.

human is such cheap animal...so much cheaper because despite being given higher intelect...what they are capable of doing is still amazing !!

comment 22 : Shame on you , you are not only racist but you are generalising as well. lack of morality knows no boundaries of race, age , colour,,educational background, faith , sexuality. do not judge or you too would be judged , for the measure you use, it would be measured to you.

27. 2011-02-28 19:05  
There's media ethics, and in the defense of what is public interest. What in Australia it is possible (if not admissible) to out someone if they are in the public service extends to everyone in India. What I'm trying to say is that the line of thinking is not as far fetched as we may think, and is a common trend amongst all media outlets in the world.

I wouldn't be surprised that TV9 is the type of channel that appeals to the lower middle class that has nothing better to do than to marginalise something that they have very little understanding in. And not realising that they are ruining lives in the process... very, very sad.

I hope the Indian men outed by this process are given the necessary support they need, in at least something that could be done something about, but getting TV9 to change their mind may be a different story.

請先登入再使用此功能。

Social


請選擇新聞及專欄版本

精選個人檔案

Now ALL members can view unlimited profiles!

Languages

View this page in a different language:

讚好

合作夥伴

 ILGA Asia - Fridae partner for LGBT rights in Asia IGLHRC - Fridae Partner for LGBT rights in Asia

Advertisement