Missoula County Courthouse, archive photograph, 10 September 2012. Missoula County Courthouse in Morning.JPG by Robby Robinette (Robbyrobin), CC BY-SA 3.0. Cropped and resized; crops under the same licence.
23 Nov 2026

Montana judge blocks enforcement of binary sex definitions

An order dated 16 November pauses SB 437’s definitions while a constitutional challenge continues.

A licence or marriage certificate shouldn’t force someone to explain private details about themselves, the people challenging Montana’s SB 437 argued. Judge Leslie Halligan has given them temporary relief.

Her 16 November order stops state officials enforcing the law’s definitions of sex while the constitutional challenge continues. The transgender, intersex and Two Spirit plaintiffs were likely to succeed on privacy and equal-protection grounds, she found.

SB 437 defines sex through reproductive anatomy and makes gender a synonym for sex. Montana defended that approach as a way to keep its laws consistent.

“Administrative convenience, clarity, and ease of implementation, standing alone, are not compelling interests,” Halligan wrote. The earlier legal framework remains in place under the injunction; a final decision on the challenge is still to come.

United States