Test 2

Please select your preferred language.

請選擇你慣用的語言。

请选择你惯用的语言。

English
中文简体
台灣繁體
香港繁體

Login

Remember Me

New to Fridae?

Fridae Mobile

Advertisement
Highlights

More About Us

19 Jul 2006

news around the world 19-jul-06

In two unprecedented cases, a former TV show host in Manila has filed a gay discrimination suit against a restaurant; in Taipei, a student has filed a suit against his parents, hospital after being locked up in psychiatric ward. In the US, Oprah Winfrey has denied rumours that she is having a gay relationship with her business partner and best friend.

Former TV show host files gay discrimination suit against Manila restaurant
A former TV show host and comedy bar performer in Manila has filed a civil case against a local restaurant after being turned away as a customer.

According to the LAGABLAB website: ''The sign (top) says that clients who are wearing sleeveless shirts, caps or hats, or sandals are not allowed inside the establishment. Inday Garutay [whose real name is Christopher Borja, above] was not wearing a sleeveless shirt, a cap/hat, or sandals, and therefore cannot be deemed by the restaurant, based on its own dress code, to be inappropriately dressed. Why then was she told to leave the establishment? Was it because they see her as mentally depraved? Incorrigibly uncool? Or perhaps the more relevant question is: where does 'slippers or flipflops are not allowed' end and 'gays are prohibited' begin?''
On July 4, 2006, Christopher Borja - whose screen name is Inday Garutay - was inside the restaurant with her partner to meet her manager and a producer for a show in Japan when she was reportedly asked to leave the restaurant. The restaurant supervisor allegedly told Borja that the establishment has a dress code and that cross-dressers like her are prohibited from entering the establishment. ("Mayroon po kaming dress code dito. Bawal po ang cross-dresser. Bawal po ang ganyang katulad mo.")

Despite being told that she was in fact already inside the establishment and that the dress code is discriminatory, the restaurant supervisor reportedly insisted that Borja should leave.

According to the Lesbian and Gay Legislative Advocacy Network-Philippines (LAGABLAB-Pilipinas) website, the complaint asserts that "while private establishments do have the right to impose a dress code, it may not - in the guise of implementing such a dress code - discriminate against individuals on the basis of his or her personal condition, i.e., sexual orientation."

The non-profit, non-partisan aniti-discrimination group believes that such a dress code is blatantly discriminatory and violates basic human rights and fundamental freedoms. It also does not conform to the human relations articles of the Civil Code.

"It's not about money; it's about my rights," said Borja who is asking for P600,000 (US$11,385) for moral and exemplary damages.

"It is not about defending the right to wear a mini-skirt inside an establishment; it is about defending a legitimate life choice," her lawyer, Jae de la Cruz, said.

LAGABLAB has called for the boycott of the establishment because of its discriminatory policies. "The pink peso should not go where lesbians and gays are not wanted," Lagablab secretary-general Jonas Bagas said.

According to Bagas, discriminatory policies against LGBTs are not uncommon. He told Fridae in an interview that some Catholic schools include a 'masculinity test' in their admission exams to screen out "effeminate" students, especially cross-dressers.

"If they flunk the masculinity test, then they are not admitted in schools. However, if they fail the test but have good academic grades, they are accepted - provided that they are under probation for one year." The said tudents are made to sign a 'pink slip' which contains a list of prohibited behaviour such as cross-dressing, wearing earrings and sporting long hair. Violators will be asked to leave the school.

LAGABLAB is also working towards the passage of the Anti-Discrimination Bill, a proposed legislation that criminalises a wide range of policies and practices that discriminate against Filipino LGBTs. The bill has been approved by the House of Representatives during the 12th Congress and is currently pending for approval in the Lower House, while the Senate Committee on Labor still has to act on several versions of the bill in the Senate.

Related site:
lagablab.wordpress.com
Taiwanese student files suit against parents, hospital for lockup in psychiatric ward
A Taiwanese university student has accused his parents of drugging him by lacing his coffee at breakfast in order to have him committed to a psychiatric ward after he told them he was gay, the Taiwan News reported Tuesday.

The lawsuit filed against the hospital and his parents stated that Su Ming-che was kept against his will in Shin Kong Memorial Hospital's psychiatric ward for 56 days. The 22-year-old charged his parents with interfering with his personal freedom and announced his intention to sever relations with them.

He told reporters on Monday that on April 29 he had breakfast with his parents at a coffee shop when he came drowsy after drinking his coffee. He said that he noticed some white powder on the rim of his coffee cup when he returned from the bathroom but thought nothing of it.

On his way to the hospital, feeling faint, he heard a doctor telling him: "Your father put drugs in your coffee, but it is all for your own good."

He also told the press conference that he was forced by this parents to undergo treatment at the Taipei Municipal Wan Fang Hospital but the doctors refused, saying they did not believe Su needed inpatient care.

"I pretended to take pills at 9 p.m. every night but then spit them out after the nurse left. I wanted to prove that I was not ill," Su said of his experience at Shin Kong Hospital where the doctor locked him up in a psychiatric ward claiming he was suffering from bipolar disorder and hallucinations, without engaging in a proper diagnosis.

He said he eventually left Shin Kong Hospital after his parents were persuaded by doctors that he was fit to be discharged. To prove that he was not mentally unstable, Su obtained certificates of diagnosis from Taipei City Hospital and National Taiwan University Hospital both of which said he was mentally sound.

The case was taken up by Huang Wei-cher, a lawmaker in Taiwan's Democratic Progressive Party who is calling for the government to reflect on whether the process for hospitalising psychiatric patients was flawed. Huang added that the Health Bureau under Taipei City Government has promised to investigate whether or not Shin Kong Hospital violated the law.

The Taiwan Times reported that Su's father told the Chinese-language tabloid Apple Daily that his son had mental problems and needed to be hospitalised.

"I can't forgive him for suing a family member. Can he say that he is not sick after he has accused his family?" the Times quoted Su's father as saying. According to local media, after the press conference, Su's mother barred her son from the house.
I'm not in a gay relationship with my best friend, says Oprah
US television talk show host Oprah Winfrey has squashed rumours of she having a romantic relationship with her business partner and best friend of 30 years, Gayle King, in an interview in the August issue of O, The Oprah Magazine. She says that she would have told her fans if it were true.

US television talk show host Oprah Winfrey (left) with her business partner and best friend of 30 years, Gayle King.
She admits that some people have misunderstood her close relationship with King - an editor on the magazine and often seen with Winfrey in public - but they are not a gay couple.

"I understand why people think we're gay," she says. "There isn't a definition in our culture for this kind of bond between women. So I get why people have to label it - how can you be this close without it being sexual?"

Winfrey's is known to be in a long-term relationship with self-help author and guru Stedman Graham for years although they two have said they have no plans to wed anytime soon.

In the magazine, Winfrey, 52, and King share details about their 30-year friendship and "four-times-a-day phone calls." They assert that they would have no problem telling the public if they were in a sexual relationship.

Says Winfrey: "Something about this relationship feels otherworldly to me, like it was designed by a power and a hand greater than my own."

"The truth is, if we were gay, we would tell you, because there's nothing wrong with being gay," 51-year-old King said.

Winfrey quipped: "I've told nearly everything there is to tell. All my stuff is out there. People think I'd be so ashamed of being gay that I wouldn't admit it? Oh, please."

Read the interview in O, The Oprah Magazine here.

Reader's Comments

1. 2006-07-19 21:59  
haha. u go girl!
tabloids!
Comment #2 was deleted by its author
3. 2006-07-20 00:10  
What's the big news about a Denial?
It's a god damn non-event

Sometimes people go overboard trying to label other people as the same kind as themselves that it becomes sickening, like some sorta obsession.

Worst of all, it taints the precedence of friendship. Calling someone 4 times a day must mean you're f@ckin' them? Jesus. Fridae's not innocent either in circulating this piece ofnews trash
4. 2006-07-20 00:21  
Usually if I'm not f'c'kin' happy with the restaurant, I'd just put a make a scene and put a brick through the window.

Putting the guy outta biz by destroying him financially is terrible. It's his fck'in' cafe....let it be.

There's some limits that's necessary,
for example dogs climbing on tables, screaming babies, loud mobile phone talkers, smokers.

Reading the article, it's not that she (or he?) is a homosexual that they kicked him/her out. It's because she's f'riggin' loud and that can sometimes douse the appetite of those next table.
5. 2006-07-20 00:23  
Can't blame them. You hurt the one you love.
6. 2006-07-20 00:48  
reply to Newmember

what you mean by - you hurt the one you love-
do you mean that the boy being gay hurt his parents?
because being gay is wrong?

If what he says is true.. at least he did came out and told his parents the truth rather then keeping them in the dark. how many of us are has that Courage to tell our parents outrightly
that we are Gay? To friends definitely.. but parents its not easy... to think he actually did that.. i think he deserves some kind of credit. At least he is trying to be honest with them after hiding who he really is from them.
7. 2006-07-20 00:52  
Poor thang...!
8. 2006-07-20 00:55  
There's a difference of Being Gay and Being Out. It's about Choices.

Don't really care if someone wants to advertise it on the newspaper.
Don't force it down someone's throat.
No one should be told they lack courage just because they are not out.

Get that, B;Tch?
Now go f@c' off
9. 2006-07-20 01:04  
reply to newmember

what is your problem?
i see you don't have much manners in you?
i am only replying to your that one line comment
and the rest is saying what i feel abt the damn article

and i did not say they are lack of courage that they are not out..
i am saying being out to PARENTS is not what everyone can do it takes ALOT OF COURAGE to actually say that.
i don't tink i ever mentioned anything abt not being out means no courage? did i?
don't twist my words to your own liking.
and mind your bloody manners
10. 2006-07-20 01:19  
i told my parents becuase i had too. lol! but i ended up on the looosing end either ways.. haha.. funny me!
11. 2006-07-20 01:21  
LOL!! its news around the world ..
12. 2006-07-20 01:27  
What tabloid? O magazine is published by Oprah Winfrey herself so it's straight from the horse's mouth.

Anyway, I've seen some of the gay episodes on Youtube such as the one on gay teens, I think Oprah is by far one of the most supportive talkshow hosts. I love the show! Given her reach, I think Oprah's shows go very far in educating the mainstream and esp mums and dads with gay children. Not only in the US but also many other parts of the world including Singapore where one almost always never hear anything postive about gays and lesbians.

She also frequently has gay guests such as Nate and her makeup artisit who are pretty camp and that normalises gay men and I believe encourage acceptance...
Comment #13 was deleted by its author
14. 2006-07-20 02:09  
No need to be nasty newmember.

No one is saying you are lacking the balls/ courage just because in your profile you are "Prefer not to say Male" although words like
1) Meaty
2) Stocky
3) Bear
4) Panda
5) G-men
"trigger the monster in you"?
15. 2006-07-20 02:10  
Newmember: "Sometimes people go overboard trying to label other people as the same kind as themselves that it becomes sickening, like some sorta obsession."

Right. What are you thoughts on people who label themselves "Prefer not to say Male" but words like
1) Meaty
2) Stocky
3) Bear
4) Panda
5) G-men
"trigger the monster in you"? Is it sickening? Or is it denial? Or some kind of obsession?
16. 2006-07-20 07:21  
InTh3EnD

Let me elaborate on - "Can't blame them. You hurt the one you love."

- The parents went to some extreme and obviously it hurt their son (putting him in a mental hospital). But they did it because they love their son. Otherwise, they'd just let him be.
Comment #17 was deleted by its author
Comment #18 was deleted by its author
19. 2006-07-20 22:52  
Hi guys, I am the one whose parents drugged me. I didn't bring anthing with me. Only had 200 NT. They gave me bills which were from my apartment( I lived alone before).
On April 29, They sent to me to th hospital. they put me as a "coercive impatient," but I didn't take any medicine on April 29 and April 30. On May 1, the doctor gave my parents a diagnosis which says I have "bipolar disorder." My parents took this diagnosis to quit my university. I asked my friend to sued them after they locked me in hospital.
If you really care about your child, you would go to hospital to visit your child soon. But after they locked me, they changed my apartment keys first. Then took my everything away. Now they still keep my everything.
I felt I could trust my parents and my family. Everyone would think parents always love their baby, I thought about that before. But maybe I put too much trust inside.
I really hope can leave Taiwan soon. My parents told the media and my school teachers I am a psycho. When I called back to school. Some teachers were afriad of picking up my phone. I even don't knwo should I go back to the university to study again!......So streeful.
20. 2006-07-21 07:23  
Oh dear......

Very sorry to hear that.
Who are we to judge what you're going through?

Hope things get better.
But you should finish your degree non the less.

Hang in there bro.
21. 2006-07-21 09:21  
Are children conceived for the sole purpose of making parents happy ? What about the happiness of the kids themselves ?
richard
22. 2006-07-22 13:23  
I am still in Taiwan for fightting back with government and the hospital. Cause today just happened on me, it could happen on anyone. Many friends asked me just leave, they think my case is normal in USA and everywhere. But it is Taiwan, I believe Taiwan is liberal and it is a beautiful place. I hope Taiwan would get better and better. That's why I still stay in Taiwan and resolving things now. Even I am poor, but my mind is not poor. The government asked me to wait for "Psychiatric Research Committee" to check my problem. I told them if they could, I has had apply for that on May 1. They didn't do that at the time and now try to waste my time. They try to cover the hospital. And now they told me they ae not sure if will be "Psychiatric Research Committee" to check my problem now.
23. 2006-07-22 13:27  
I think that this person deserves all the surport the gay community can give him .
24. 2006-07-24 13:58  
Hey Benny,
You Rock dude. You're proof to everyone in Taiwan, and places like it. That there is nothing wrong with being gay. Your courage is inspirational. Guys like you make being gay a little bit easier for all those who come after you. Be strong stay brave. You have the admiration of everyone gay person who reads this story.

Comment #25 was deleted by its author
26. 2006-07-24 22:33  
My friend asked me to leave taiwan, but I think it's a big thing for me , also for anyone who hasn't got this problem. The point is not only I am gay. It's about the healthy system problem. How could they make the dignosis which I have "Biopolar Desorder" in 2 days? Especiallly I have never been to that hospital before. In this world, people should believe who has good ability, not facous on who is gay and who is not. Being gay is not a shame....If you agree with me, please give me a vote(Leave your message and telll me your opinion then) :-)
27. 2006-07-26 23:28  
Yo Benny,
I think they should nail the guys who misdiagnosed you. Nevertheless, I have a good friend who is Bipolar and I don't think there's anything wrong with him. In fact he's really intelligent, just a bit moody

Please log in to use this feature.

Social


This article was recently read by

Select News Edition

Featured Profiles

Now ALL members can view unlimited profiles!

Languages

View this page in a different language:

Like Us on Facebook

Partners

 ILGA Asia - Fridae partner for LGBT rights in Asia IGLHRC - Fridae Partner for LGBT rights in Asia

Advertisement