Test 2

Please select your preferred language.

請選擇你慣用的語言。

请选择你惯用的语言。

English
中文简体
台灣繁體
香港繁體

登入

記住我

初到 Fridae?

Fridae Mobile

Advertisement
Highlights

More About Us

新聞&特寫

« 較新的 | 較舊的 »
30 Sep 2009

Being gay, Muslim and Indonesian

Although homosexuality is not punishable by law in Indonesia, many gay Indonesians experience personal conflict and face condemnation from religious leaders. Hera Diani writes in The Jakarta Globe.

The following is an excerpt from The Jakarta Globe. For the full article, follow the link at the end of the page.
Despite living under the same roof for years, Fachri (not his real name) thought his father had no clue that he was gay. But around five years ago, when he borrowed his father’s Koran to research a project, he was surprised to find certain verses underlined in pencil.
They were about God’s wrath toward people who committed acts of sexual deviance during the time of Prophet Luth (or Lot), the Islamic equivalent of the Sodom and Gomorrah text in the Bible.
Growing up in a religious family that adheres to Islamic teachings, it was not the first time Fachri had come across the verses. It was sort of touching, he said, how his father seemed to want to know him better, although he wished it was not through the religious text he despised.
“The text was one of the reasons why I decided to renounce my religion. I have lost faith in any kind of religion because it excludes us, condemns us,” said the 31-year-old advertising executive. “It creates an absolute border, whereas a human being is a complex thing. 
“Why should I embrace religion when it doesn’t accept us? Why should I adhere to Islam, or any religion for that matter, when there is no space for me?”
In Indonesia, where religion plays a dominant role in society and where 90 percent of the population is Muslim, homosexuality is not punishable by law but condemnation of homosexuality has been voiced by many religious leaders, not only Islamic.
Muslims praying in a mosque. 
A scene from A Jihad for Love, an 
award-winning documentary about gay Muslims.

The following is an excerpt from
The Jakarta Globe. For the full article, follow the link at the end of the page.

Despite living under the same roof for years, Fachri (not his real name) thought his father had no clue that he was gay. But around five years ago, when he borrowed his father’s Koran to research a project, he was surprised to find certain verses underlined in pencil.

They were about God’s wrath toward people who committed acts of sexual deviance during the time of Prophet Luth (or Lot), the Islamic equivalent of the Sodom and Gomorrah text in the Bible.

Growing up in a religious family that adheres to Islamic teachings, it was not the first time Fachri had come across the verses. It was sort of touching, he said, how his father seemed to want to know him better, although he wished it was not through the religious text he despised.

“The text was one of the reasons why I decided to renounce my religion. I have lost faith in any kind of religion because it excludes us, condemns us,” said the 31-year-old advertising executive. “It creates an absolute border, whereas a human being is a complex thing.

“Why should I embrace religion when it doesn’t accept us? Why should I adhere to Islam, or any religion for that matter, when there is no space for me?”

In Indonesia, where religion plays a dominant role in society and where 90 percent of the population is Muslim, homosexuality is not punishable by law but condemnation of homosexuality has been voiced by many religious leaders, not only Islamic.

Indonesia

讀者回應

1. 2009-09-30 21:31  
news editor, there you go again...

can you at least try and pace your articles....what is it with the obsession with the muslims, indonesia and malaysia ....can you take a break...how about gerard butler's butt for a change...

get the gist?
修改於2009-09-30 21:33:05
2. 2009-09-30 22:10  
I personally liked the article. Thought it offers a broad range of complex perspectives into like a small, digestible, not really toe stepping manner.
3. 2009-10-01 04:06  
It seems to me that Fridae, as a Singapore-based, primarily Asian gay site is rightly interested in matters which affect gays in Asian countries and religions. I'm half-Thai, half-American, New Zealand citizen, and I appreciate Fridae's 'obsessions'. This one was interesting.
4. 2009-10-01 06:59  
This article is very informative for people in the West i.e. Christian world. Many gay people, raised as Christians, reject religion because it preaches love and acceptance but does not practise those things. Christ apparently accepted everyone. His churches do not.
The main reason for Chistians not being gay friendly is the writings of St Paul. He has recently been outed as a closet gay similar to Hoover in the USA who persecuted gays. There is a long history of gays in the church contributing a great deal from painting and sculpture to scripture. The church has a real problem because it is in denial.
It may be similar in all the other great religions.
5. 2009-10-01 09:12  
The full article in Jakarta Globe merely goes to point out that there are gays out there who try to intersect their beliefs in their religion with their homosexuality.

While it merely highlights the Muslims of Indonesia, I think Dina Zaman in her book, 'I Am Muslim', posted an interview with a lesbian who states the same stance.

And I am sure that this is not limited to simply Muslims, but every religion.

I respect that.
6. 2009-10-01 18:20  
I've been there and I am still, 'til.........
修改於2009-10-01 18:23:25
7. 2009-10-01 19:54  
the editor dont have new issue to bring up......
8. 2009-10-01 20:13  
again ... separation of church (in this case, mosque) and state ...

too tired and sleepy to write anymore ... but keyword is ... "interpretation" ... of religious views and texts ... thats gotta be worked on ... for this time and age ... and people and place ...

good nite zzz
9. 2009-10-01 20:18  
my best friends are indonesians
my best boyfriends are indonesians
my best vanilla sex i had with indonesians
my best raunchy sex i had with indonesians
my best girl friends are indonesians

I hope this stays like this...
10. 2009-10-01 21:55  
and because Im indonesian, Im totally agree with this article ;)
回應#11於於2009-10-01 22:40被作者刪除。
12. 2009-10-01 22:39  
I guess this article does reveal one real life example of how the Secular State and Religion could co-exist. Indonesia is the world's largest Islamic nation. It is also the largest democracy in Southeast Asia. If the country's lawmakers, most Muslim, had adopted the view of a well-known professor in Singapore, that "While religion is personal, it is not exclusively private and has a social dimension which is not to be trivialised.", the majority of them could have easily voted for it to adopt Islamic Law. Under Islamic Law, homosexuality would be illegal.

Consequently, Muslims in Indonesia have a choice to renounce their religion and be free to follow just the laws of the State, instead of that of both the State and Islam. Individuals like Farchi can then face both himself and others more genuinely, instead of having to wear a thick mask and to feel constant guilt as a sinner.

Great, isn't it, for a country as rural and religious as Indonesia where more than 90% of the people are Muslim to condone homosexuality under their state law? Disheartening, isn't it, for a country as developed and secular as Singapore to keep 377a when virtually ALL other developed countries had removed their 377a-equivalents? USA, UK, Australia, New Zealand, Canada.......you name it.

Talking about conservativeness, I really can't see how Singaporeans could be more conservative than Indonesians. Neither can I see why 377a must stay in our books in order to please (only) those whose faiths view it as a sin, when Indonesia has already proven that their significantly more religious, conservative population CAN condone homosexuality under state law. Hence, the case of Indonesia simply tells us that the reason given by Singapore's government for keeping 377a (being that the majority in Singapore are conservative) is invalid.
13. 2009-10-02 06:50  
this obsessions abt muslims, malaysia, and indonesia is nothing surprising coming from tiny little red dot of singapore, to view on the popular propaganda abt singapore's mainly malay muslim neighbors from predominantly chinese singapore. but coming from fridae itself, its kinda feel a bit double standard. its like u can take gay out from the chinese singaporeans but not the sino elements from the gay singaporeans. shame really.
14. 2009-10-02 11:03  
I didn't know that Indonesia govt allows a muslim to renounce his religion. That's interesting.

“The text was one of the reasons why I decided to renounce my religion. I have lost faith in any kind of religion because it excludes us, condemns us,” said the 31-year-old advertising executive. “It creates an absolute border, whereas a human being is a complex thing.

“Why should I embrace religion when it doesn’t accept us? Why should I adhere to Islam, or any religion for that matter, when there is no space for me?”

These statements are strong and well-said.
15. 2009-10-02 11:47  
I thought the above article is exactly what we should support and want to see more of in the mainstream media.

It seems like some people here are in the same mind as the Singapore authorities who I see as trying to suppress any kind of dialogue about being gay and Muslim by banning A Jihad for Love at the last minute.

But I read that the film will be shown at the upcoming Freedom Film Festival this month in 4 cities in Malaysia

2-4 OCTOBER 2009, The Annexe, Central Market KL
9-11 OCTOBER 2009, Han Chiang College, Penang
23-25 OCTOBER, Sekolah Menengah Chung Hua No.1, Kuching
30 OCTOBER-1 NOVEMBER, Tropical Inn, Johor Bharu

freedomfilmfest.komas.org
16. 2009-10-02 16:08  
for fuck sake! ( pardon my language!) no religion in this world as far as i concerned supports gay and lesbian for that matter. god doesn't make junk..it doesn't matter what religion you are..just life your life as you wanted it to be. i was born and grew up muslim...focking proud of it....i suck cocks but i still have faith in my religion...so what? why do we gay people always wrapped around our life with this issue? enough drama! move on.
17. 2009-10-02 18:33  
Post 16 - armatevi - There are indeed religions that accept gays, and branches of the Abrahamic religions that accept them. But it's mainly the Abrahamic ones that are actively used to persecute them.

You ask "why do we gay people always wrapped around our life with this issue?" . Because from Jamaica to Iran, from Texas to Moscow, people use religion as an excuse to murder, execute, beat and imprison us, to fire us, lie about us, deny us access to medical treatment, ban us from TV and cinema, and to impose their anti-gay rules and laws on us. And they claim immunity from criticism and exemptions from anti-hate legislation, by saying it's their "religion" or shrug and say "it's written".

Sure, if you're lucky enough to be in a place where you think such things do not directly impact your life, you can get by; but why not spare a thought for the less fortunate?

If it really doesn't bother you that Aceh nearly had the death penalty for gays because of some religious extremists in your faith, maybe one day it will, when you are more directly affected.
18. 2009-10-03 18:36  
post 17 - another drama!
19. 2009-10-04 18:19  
fortunately,even many religion leader condemn gays and lesbians, but culture of indonesians kinda accept it.
transexual in indonesia is a common,not being condemned but they're in very low level in society.
if we talk bout religions,especially religions based on abraham's inheritance,homosexual is prohibited...
no clue at all
20. 2009-10-06 18:04  
The film "A Jihad for Love" brings home the point that one can be a practicing homosexual and a practicing Muslim (or Christian for that matter) at the same time. The two are not necessarily mutually exclusive or in conflict with each other. There is room for gays, lesbians and transgenders in Islam or any religion of peace and love for that matter. And that room is independent reasoning. Gay and lesbian Muslims can learn to reclaim the true reading of the Qur'an based on common sense and compassion rather than the traditional reading defined by a heterosexual majority. The same goes for LGBTIQ Christians. The Abrahamic religions do not condemn homosexuality that is based on love as is popularly believed. What is condemned is homosexual rape and violence. Yes the majority can be wrong when they follow the crowd instead of thinking critically without any prior assumptions. I do not blame Fachri for renouncing Islam (or anyone for renouncing Christianity) if they have been hurt by those who abuse the religion. Each one has a right to express one's spirituality the way that is most comfortable and appealing to one personally. Religion does not count, but spirituality does. Ultimately the measure of our character is in doing what is good and right to others in the spirit of love and compassion.

請先登入再使用此功能。

請選擇新聞及專欄版本

精選個人檔案

Now ALL members can view unlimited profiles!

Languages

View this page in a different language:

讚好

合作夥伴

 ILGA Asia - Fridae partner for LGBT rights in Asia IGLHRC - Fridae Partner for LGBT rights in Asia

Advertisement